Twidrew Umbrum Dinky convinced me to poison molestias milkshake Posted 3 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Space Case Derp is best Nov. 1 That would be quite a twist. Posted 4 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Background Pony #39A6 My body, might be ready for you, Trixieee. Posted 4 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Ba'al Pungo I discover that Pinkamena is my daughter from the future. What sort of response could I possibly give that? Posted 5 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
MezzoDragon Pathetic Failure @Algebroot Neogears This works well. Rainbow doesn’t like pie and Lyra is, more or less, a unicorn version of Pinkie Pie. Posted 5 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Algebroot Neogears Metafiction & Horror Fan Rainbow Dash bakes a pie for me, only to smash it into Lyra’s face. Posted 5 years ago Report Edited 5 years ago Link Quote Reply
DEADSKILL @Background Pony #4016 Touring the wonderbolt academy maybe? Posted 6 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Background Pony #716A I walk into Spitfire and Dashie bathing together… Howd I end up in the Wonderbolts lockerroom? Posted 6 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
DEADSKILL Chrysalis makes me a pie and but before i can eat it she smashes it into vinyl scratches face. Should have expected that… Posted 6 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Ba'al Pungo Pinkamena Diane Pie would be my daughter from the future. MY GOD, WHAT HAVE I DONE? Posted 9 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Background Pony #2073 I enter the bathroom to pee but then I see Pinkie and Flutters in the bath. My eyes widen as I move back and close the door slowly while exclaiming “awkward…”. Posted 9 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
DudeNin64 Some random brony TWINKLESHINE, GIVE THAT CONTROLLER NOW! Posted 9 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
TheMushroomVestal Owain from Fire Emblem has swordfight with Dinky and Celestia over a pit of snakes. HIS SWORD HAND TWITCHES! Posted 10 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
mrdoctorderpy I wake up to find out that I’m princess Molestia’s foal. I don’t know if that’s a bad thing or not Posted 10 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
PonyFreeman I fathered Spitfire. Dash would kill to meet me then. Posted 10 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
TheOtherPinkiePie Bleh... Yeah, Derpy! Smash that pie into Trixie’s face! Posted 10 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Timstro59 A FoE: PH fan @xale Who did you fuck for that to happen? Posted 11 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
xale I discover Discord is my son from the future!!!! Holy crap! Posted 11 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Valiant Spiral Chaos Within Harmony So…my future daughter is fanonically known as the town drunkard? Posted 11 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
Background Pony #1351 Molestia its to me that Luna is deeply in love with me. Seems like something’s she’d do. Posted 12 years ago Report Link Quote Reply
What sort of response could I possibly give that?
This works well. Rainbow doesn’t like pie and Lyra is, more or less, a unicorn version of Pinkie Pie.
Edited
Only if you say it is
Oops, wrong turn
Touring the wonderbolt academy maybe?
Howd I end up in the Wonderbolts lockerroom?
MY GOD, WHAT HAVE I DONE?
I don’t know if that’s a bad thing or not
I guess Discord’s mom.
Who did you fuck for that to happen?